10 Fall Bakery Cozy Mysteries Filled with Pies, Pumpkins & Murder

Is there anything better than walking into a bakery on a crisp autumn morning? The scent of cinnamon and nutmeg fills the air, pumpkin muffins are coming out of the oven, apple pies line the counter, and somewhere in the kitchen a fresh batch of maple-glazed something is probably cooling on a rack.

Unless, of course, there’s also a dead body.

Bakeries have long been favorite settings for cozy mysteries, but they’re especially irresistible in autumn, when the pastry cases fill with apples, pumpkins, maple syrup, warm spices, and all the comforting flavors of the season. These ten mysteries combine bakeries and baking with harvest festivals, orchards, Halloween celebrations, and plenty of fall atmosphere.

This post contains Amazon Associate affiliate links. When you purchase any of these books by using these links, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

The Pumpkin Vice Cafe by Ellie Alexander

Autumn has settled over Ashland, Oregon, in a blaze of color, and Jules Capshaw and the crew at Torte are filling their pastry cases with pumpkin coffee cake, cupcakes, croissants, and other seasonal treats. Jules is also awaiting the arrival of twins while her friends Lance and Arlo plan their wedding.

Then their high-end wedding planner is found dead in the icy waters of Ashland Creek. What initially appears to be a tragic fall from a bridge begins looking suspicious, and Jules once again trades her baking tools for amateur detective work. With November foliage, pumpkin baked goods, spicy lattes, chilly weather, and a bustling bakery, this forthcoming September 2026 release is practically made for fall reading.

Murder at the Pumpkin Pageant by Darci Hannah

Halloween weekend has arrived in Beacon Harbor, Michigan, where baker Lindsey Bakewell is embracing the season with pumpkin-flavored goodies and cheerful autumn decorations at her lighthouse bakery. She’s less enthusiastic about the teenagers trying to visit the lighthouse’s resident ghost—or the professional ghost hunters her best friend has invited to conduct a livestream investigation.

Then Lindsey discovers that what appears to be a creepy Halloween decoration hanging from a tree is actually a corpse. Between pumpkin scones, costumes, ghost hunting, a Pumpkin Pageant, and a bakery housed inside a haunted lighthouse, this one delivers fall atmosphere by the basketful.

Pumpkin Spice Peril by Jenn McKinlay

Melanie Cooper and Angie Harper’s Fairy Tale Cupcakes is thriving, and one of their most devoted customers is local glass artist Rene Fischer-Klein. Every week Rene’s husband brings her a box containing her favorite cupcakes—but when Rene suddenly dies, police discover that she was poisoned.

The problem? Among the last things she ate were Fairy Tale Cupcakes’ signature pumpkin-spice cupcakes. With the bakery’s reputation at stake, Mel and Angie need to determine whether someone used their seasonal treats to deliver a deadly ingredient.

This tasty mystery made it onto my list of pumpkin spice cozies, too!

Killer Donuts by Ginger Bolton

It’s fall in Fallingbrook, Wisconsin, and Deputy Donut Café owner Emily Westhill is hitting the local “Donut Trail,” a seasonal tour featuring pre-Halloween treats and activities. Amid brilliant fall foliage, Emily and her friends stop at an orchard offering cider, a corn maze, and plenty of autumn fun.

But a disagreeable tourist disappears inside the maze and later turns up dead. Unfortunately, evidence points toward Emily and her friends. With apple cider, pumpkins, a corn maze, Halloween treats, spectacular foliage—and, naturally, doughnuts—this August 2026 release checks nearly every box on the fall-cozy list.

Apple Pie and Alibis by Nova Walsh

September has arrived in Moonstone Bay, bringing chilly mornings and a new fall menu to Ginny Malone’s Moonstone Bakery. Ginny takes a rare day away from the ovens to visit her boyfriend Vince’s family apple orchard, where she expects picturesque scenery and perhaps a few apples for the bakery.

Instead, Ginny and Vince discover a body among the trees, and Vince’s brother becomes caught in the resulting scandal. Soon Ginny is shuttling between the orchard and her bakery, balancing murder suspects with early-morning baking and trays of freshly made apple hand pies.

Maple Pie Murder by Kathleen Suzette

Fall has arrived in Sandy Harbor, Maine, bringing crisp weather and the aromas of cinnamon, nutmeg, and maple syrup. Baker Allie is preparing her grandmother’s treasured maple-pie recipe for the town’s Harvest Festival when a well-known local resident is found dead.

While her detective husband handles the official investigation, Allie begins asking questions of her own. The combination of a Maine autumn, Harvest Festival, family recipes, small-town secrets, and plenty of maple pies makes this 2026 mystery especially suited to sweater-and-blanket reading.

Pumpkin Spice Spells by Sara Bourgeois

Ivy Merriweather returns to Harvest Hollow to help save her family bakery, Witchcakes, just as the town enters its busiest season: Halloween. The bakery is overflowing with pumpkin-spice cupcakes and enchanted recipes, and Ivy soon discovers that a little kitchen magic might be part of her inheritance.

Then a member of the Halloween festival committee is found dead behind the bakery. After suspicion falls on Witchcakes, Ivy must uncover the killer while protecting the family business—with assistance, or perhaps interference, from an orange cat named Nutmeg.

Pumpkin Spice and Peril by Maisy Marple

Rosie Brennan loves October in Harvest Hollow, especially the changing leaves, crisp air, and endless opportunities to bake pumpkin-spice treats at the Harvest Moon Bakery. Her idyllic season takes a turn when a local woman publicly accuses Rosie of stealing a treasured family recipe.

Within twenty-four hours, the woman is dead—and a piece of cake in Harvest Moon Bakery packaging is found with her body. With the sheriff looking closely at Rosie, the baker must follow the crumbs herself to discover who turned her favorite season into a recipe for murder.

Which of these bakery-themed cozies are your favorites? Share your choices below.

Murder at the Bramblewood Bakery by Margaret Wren

Retired librarian Eleanor Marsh is looking forward to a quiet autumn in the English village of Bramblewood—and to finally winning the village Harvest Bake-Off. Standing in her way is rival baker Vivienne Caldwell.

Then Vivienne is found poisoned by her own almond tart, and Eleanor lands at the top of the suspect list. With decades of village feuds and secrets to sort through, the former librarian decides to apply her research skills to murder. An English village, autumn, a harvest baking competition, and suspicious pastries give this 2026 mystery plenty of seasonal appeal.

Murder at the Harvest Festival by Poppy Waverly

The annual Harvest Festival in the coastal town of Seagrove Harbor should be a celebration of food, friendship, and community. Instead, beloved local grocer Maria Alvarez collapses after sampling her own salsa—and bakery-and-café owner Lila McAllister suspects there is more to her friend’s death than meets the eye.

Lila teams up with Maria’s niece to investigate a tangle of jealousy, ambition, tampered ingredients, and long-held secrets. With a bakery owner as the amateur sleuth and a bustling harvest festival providing the backdrop, this is an easy fit for an autumn bakery reading list.

A Recipe for the Perfect Fall Mystery

Autumn and bakeries might be one of the coziest combinations imaginable. The season practically begs for ovens to be turned on and mixing bowls pulled from cupboards. Apples become pies, pumpkins become muffins and cakes, maple syrup finds its way into everything, and cinnamon suddenly seems like an essential food group.

Add a small town, a harvest festival, an inquisitive baker, and a suspicious death, and you have all the ingredients for a classic cozy mystery.

Don't miss another post! Sign up for my monthly newsletter to get post links delivered right to your inbox, as well as exclusive reader news, special offers, and more!